Oklahoma bishops praise new protections for Catholic adoption agencies


Oklahoma City, Okla., May 14, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- With the signing of a bill preserving the religious freedom of adoption agencies in Oklahoma, Gov. Mary Fallin drew praise from the state’s Catholic bishops on Friday.

“We are grateful for Gov. Fallin’s support of religious liberty in Oklahoma. The new law will bring more adoption services to the state and allow crucial faith-based agencies to continue their decades-long tradition of caring for Oklahoma’s most vulnerable children,” Archbishop Paul Coakley of Oklahoma City and Bishop David Konderla of Tulsa said May 11.

“Since the law does not change the process for placing foster children or ban any family from adopting, we hope and pray this action will increase the number of children matched with loving families,” said the bishops.

The bill, S.B. 1140, passed the Senate by a vote of 33-7 and the House of Representatives by 56-21. In the House, legislators opposed to the bill tried to make various parliamentary measures to prevent a full vote and at one point were warned that further disruption would result in their removal, the Catholic Conference of Oklahoma reported.

Fallin said the bill “allows faith-based agencies that contract with Oklahoma to continue to operate in accordance with their beliefs. In a day and time when diversity is becoming a core value to society because it will lead to more options, we should recognize its value for serving Oklahoma also because it leads to more options for loving homes to serve Oklahoma children.”

“Other states that have declined the protection to faith-based agencies have seen these agencies close their doors, leaving less options for successful placement of children who need loving parents,” she said, according to the Tulsa World.

Catholic adoption and foster placement agencies in Illinois, Massachusetts, and the District of Columbia, among others, have been forced to close because of laws or funding restrictions that would require them to place children with same-sex couples or with unmarried heterosexual couples.

The Baptist General Convention of Oklahoma was among the other backers of the Oklahoma bill.

The bill’s text bars requiring a private child-placement agency to perform, assist, counsel, recommend, consent to, refer, or participate in a placement of a child for foster care and adoption should such a placement “violate the agency’s written religious or moral convictions or policies.”

It also bars denying licenses or state or local grants to agencies that act on religious or moral objections. Further, the law protects them from civil action.

Critics of the bill charged that it was discriminatory and unconstitutional.

Denise Brogan-Kator, chief policy officer for the Family Equality Council, contended it sent the message that LGBTQ people should not raise children, the New York Times reports.

Toby Jenkins, executive director of the LGBT activist group Oklahomans for Equality, charged that taxpayer dollars were being used to discriminate against both couples and children waiting for placement.

“Oklahomans for Equality is deeply disappointed in the governor’s lack of leadership. The pervasive and persistent mean-spirited legislative efforts continue to be day-to-day business in Oklahoma,” he said, suggesting recourse to the Oklahoma Supreme Court would be considered.

However, several legal scholars backed the bill’s constitutionality in an April 12 letter to State Rep. Travis Dunlap and State Sen. Greg Treat. Constitutional criticisms of the Oklahoma bill are, in their view, “obstructionist objections with no basis in existing law or in original understanding.”

The letter’s signers were professors Michael A. Scaperlanda of the University of Oklahoma College of Law; Richard W. Garnett of the University of Notre Dame Law School; Douglas Laycock of the University of Virginia School of Law; and Thomas C. Berg of Minnesota’s University of St. Thomas School of Law.

“The Supreme Court is deeply divided on the question of whether religious exemptions are sometimes constitutionally required. But the Court has repeatedly been unanimous in support of the view that religious exemptions are constitutionally permitted,” they wrote.

“This provision would create an exemption from any provision of state law that might otherwise require an agency to violate its religious commitments,” they said, saying such exemptions have been an American legal tradition since the 1600s.

They cited a 1992 study which estimated there are 2,000 religious exemptions under federal and state laws. Many more exemptions have been enacted since then.

While there are limits to appropriate bounds of religious exemptions, the scholars said, the Oklahoma bill “does not come close to triggering any of these limitations.”

The 61 state-monitored child placement agencies in Oklahoma make “an ample number to meet the diverse needs of all Oklahomans, including LGBT children and LGBT adoptive parents.” With these “readily available alternatives,” said the scholars, the bill is “a model of liberty and justice for all.”

“The religious providers need not violate their conscience, and the needs of all Oklahomans are served.”

While critics of the bill had charged that it constituted the unconstitutional establishment of religion, the scholars said “exemptions are not a way of expanding the power of the dominant religion; they are a way of protecting religions that lack the political power to prevent legislation or court decisions that impose substantial burdens on their religious practice.”

“Government does not establish a religion by leaving it alone. The Supreme Court has repeatedly, and unanimously, so held,” they continued.

Receiving government funding does not bind private organizations to be treated as if they were state agencies, they explained: “if a child-placing agency with state funding chooses to act in accord with its religious convictions, the state has not directed that choice, the state is not responsible for it, and the child-placing agency’s choice is not state action.”

Fallin said similar legislation has existed in Virginia since 2012 without any court challenges. Five additional states have similar legislation, while Kansas Gov. Jeff Coyler has said he will sign legislation recently passed by the state legislature.

Fallin said the bill would not affect any current practices allowing LGBTQ individuals and couples to foster and adopt. She said she is committed to “preserving the rights of all Oklahomans who are eligible and want to be considered for parenting.” She announced a planned executive order directing the state’s Department of Health and Human Services to publish on its website a list of Oklahoma adoption and foster care agencies who are “willing to serve everyone” who meets the state’s adoptive parent criteria.

A significant advocacy campaign to limit religious freedom protections is underway across the U.S. CNA reports have found at least $8.5 million in earmarked grants from several wealthy funders, including some of the most influential foundations in the country. Many of these funders are now working together through the Massachusetts-based Proteus Fund’s Rights, Faith & Democracy Collaborative, which says it opposes “the inappropriate use of religious exemptions to curtail reproductive health, rights and justice, discriminate against members of the LGBTQ community, and otherwise undermine fundamental rights and liberties essential to a healthy democracy.”

Pro-life pregnancy center demands removal from 'libelous' video

Denver, Colo., May 24, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- A video that frames a Colorado women’s clinic as a bogus, sub-par healthcare provider is libelous, ...

Foreign bishops respond to German intercommunion proposal

Philadelphia, Pa., May 23, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Several bishops from outside Germany have critiqued a proposal to allow Protestant spouses of Catholics ...

Humanae Vitae needs no update, commission chair says

Vatican City, May 23, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- The professor who chaired a Vatican study group on Humanae Vitae stressed that the Bl. Paul VI’s ...

Christian crowd vows to 'reclaim Jesus' from polarized U.S.

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Saying that Jesus Christ has been "hijacked" in the name of politics, a large crowd of national Christian leaders and members of their ...

Marriage proclaims 'love is possible,' pope says

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Marriage is a sacrament not only for the bride and groom, but for the entire Catholic Church, because it proclaims that "love is ...

Abortion doesn't protect women's human rights, Vatican official says

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- It is a contradiction to claim that promoting access to safe abortions is somehow protecting the human rights of women and girls, ...

More annulment processes done for free, Vatican statistics show

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Implementation of Pope Francis' abbreviated process for declaring the nullity of a marriage got off to a slow start, Vatican statistics ...

Report: Pope Francis affirms Church practice against admitting gay men to seminary

Vatican City, May 24, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- In a closed-door speech to Italian bishops on Monday, Pope Francis reportedly spoke about the number and quality ...

American seminarians to battle for the title in Rome soccer tournament

Rome, Italy, May 25, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- For the first time in five years, seminarians and student priests from the North American College in Rome will ...

Cardinal ordains seven priests for the Archdiocese of Boston

MISSION HILL -- Maria Hewett remembers her brother Baldemar Garza blessing her, back when they were both young kids. Three or four at the time, it's one ...

Local faith leaders, scientists call for action on climate change in joint appeal

BRAINTREE -- A joint statement released May 23 and signed by hundreds of scientists and faith leaders, including Cardinal Seán P. O'Malley, calls ...

Faith and Science Joint Appeal for Climate Action

The following appeal was signed by more than 500 hundred of Massachusetts religious leaders and scientists including Cardinal Seán P. O'Malley, Archbishop ...

Catholic Memorial dedicates student commons in memory of Father Dan Kennedy

WEST ROXBURY -- The newly renovated student commons at Catholic Memorial School (CM) in West Roxbury, an all-boys college preparatory school, was dedicated ...

Little Sisters of the Poor fundraising dinner

SOMERVILLE -- The sound of chatter and laughter grew louder as you walked into the Little Sisters of the Poor's 6th annual "Sharing the Vision of St. ...

21 receive Theological Institute degrees

BRIGHTON -- Dressed in caps and gowns and surrounded by family and friends, the Theological Institute of the New Evangelization's class of 2018 received ...

Future Catholic School leaders gather to reflect on training

BRAINTREE -- For the past year, new leaders and apprentice principals from schools throughout the Archdiocese have received professional development and ...

In her illness and death, a girl brings others closer to God

BRAINTREE -- Andrea Villalba, an eighth-grader at St. Joseph School in Needham, said she thinks about her friend Christina Dangond Lacouture every day, ...

From Cardinal Seán's blog

Catholic Charities' Spring Celebration Last Thursday (5/10) I went to the Park Plaza Hotel in Boston to attend Catholic Charities' annual Spring Celebration. My ...

New Vatican document on economy given high marks in U.S.

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- A new Vatican document on the economy, which contains a strong emphasis on financial transactions and maneuvers, is getting a warm ...

Cardinal: Communion cannot be shared with friends like beer or cake

BUCKFASTLEIGH, England (CNS) -- Holy Communion is exclusively for Catholics in a state of grace and not something to be shared between friends like beer ...

Italian nun murdered in Somalia to be beatified in Italy

NAIROBI, Kenya (CNS) -- An Italian Consolata sister murdered in Somalia in 2006 will be beatified in Piacenza, Italy, May 26. Sister Leonella Sgorbati ...

Nicaraguan bishops end role as mediators in national dialogue

MEXICO CITY (CNS) -- Nicaragua's bishops have suspended their participation as mediators and witnesses in a national dialogue, citing a "lack of consensus ...

Ryan, Brownback, archbishop address National Catholic Prayer Breakfast

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- This year's National Catholic Prayer breakfast took on a decidedly Kansas flavor, as Archbishop Joseph F. Naumann of Kansas City and ...

Pakistani cardinal-designate known for developing interfaith harmony

KARACHI, Pakistan (CNS) -- Cardinal-designate Joseph Coutts sees himself as a conductor -- not of musicians but of religious leaders from various faiths. He ...

Students say FOCUS mission trips strengthen their faith, desire to serve

DENVER (CNS) -- In March, Ryan Clydesdale was looking forward to heading to Hawaii with friends for spring break, "but deep down I kept feeling pulled" ...

Japanese cardinal-designate writes haiku, works with disabled

TOKYO (CNS) -- Cardinal-designate Thomas Aquinas Manyo Maeda of Osaka was more surprised than anyone at the news he is to become a cardinal, reported ...

U.S. Catholics donate nearly $59 million to hurricane, earthquake relief

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- U.S. Catholics have donated close to $59 million to relief and recovery efforts in response to the destruction caused by three hurricanes ...

Ninja priest? Meet the unlikely new contestant on a hit TV show

Little Rock, Ark., May 23, 2018 CNA.- Among the contestants on season 10 of NBC’s American Ninja Warrior, there’s one who stands out. In ...

Does God make people gay? A theologian responds

Washington D.C., May 22, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Sexual attraction does not define identity, a priest has said, after comments attributed to Pope Francis ...

Dolan: Pope's reported remarks to gay man, while 'beautiful,' could require clarification

New York City, N.Y., May 22, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- The Archbishop of New York said Tuesday that while some recent comments about homosexuality attributed ...

Mexican cardinal-designate 'very close to the people,' did not seek power

MEXICO CITY (CNS) -- Cardinal-designate Sergio Obeso Rivera, retired archbishop of Xalapa, left a towering legacy when he retired in 2007. He became a ...

Abuse survivor says pope told him God loves him the way he is

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- An abuse survivor, who had been disparaged for being a homosexual, said that Pope Francis told him that God made him that way and ...

Church official cautiously optimistic about DACA bills before Congress

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- The executive director of the U.S. bishops' Migration and Refugee Services gives credit to a group of moderate Republicans in Congress ...

A hospice that hurried death? Texas courts to weigh criminal charges

Dallas, Texas, May 21, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- In a legal case that includes allegations of death-hastening drug use and falsified do-not-resuscitate orders, ...

Pope Francis: Like Mary, the Church is a mother

Vatican City, May 21, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Pope Francis celebrated the first feast of Mary, Mother of the Church Monday saying that without the emphasis ...

Chilean bishop suspends 12 priests, apologizes for not acting sooner

Rancagua, Chile, May 21, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Over the weekend, Chilean Bishop Alejandro Goi? Karmeli? suspended several priests after allegations of ...

Cardinal stats: Pope makes college more international, not much younger

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Although it is not unusual for a pope to set aside temporarily the limit of 120 cardinals under the age of 80, Pope Francis has ...

Analysis: With new appointments, Pope Francis puts his mark on the College of Cardinals

Vatican City, May 21, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Pope Francis’ fifth consistory marks an important shift within the College of Cardinals: it is the ...

Archbishop: Naming Chaldean as cardinal is gift to struggling church

BEIRUT (CNS) -- Pope Francis' naming of Chaldean Patriarch Louis Raphael I Sako as cardinal is a gift to the Chaldean Catholic church, which has been ...

Catholic college graduates urged to make difference for those in need

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- University of Notre Dame graduates were asked May 21 to take stock of where they are going and what they will do with their talents. "Today ...

Turn to prayer when feeling despair, archbishop tells Mideast Christians

JERUSALEM (CNS) -- Even in times of violence and despair, the power of joint prayer for peace can be felt, said Archbishop Pierbattista Pizzaballa, apostolic ...

On Pentecost, Irish bishops urge a 'no' vote on abortion referendum

DUBLIN (CNS) -- Irish bishops used Pentecost Sunday Masses to make a final appeal for people to reject a government proposal to remove the right to life ...

Pope moves 12 sainthood causes ahead, including U.S. missionary's

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Pope Francis issued decrees recognizing that 12 candidates for sainthood, including U.S. Sacred Heart Brother Norbert McAuliffe, ...

Brief biographical sketches of 14 new cardinals

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Here are brief biographical notes about each of the 14 churchmen who will become cardinals June 29. Their names are listed in the ...

The Holy Spirit changes hearts, pope says on Pentecost

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Christians should begin each day invoking the Holy Spirit, praying that the Spirit will lead them and the church closer to God and ...

Pope announces June 29 consistory to create 14 new cardinals

Vatican City, May 20, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- There will be a consistory June 29 to create 14 new cardinals, each of whom express the “universality” ...