A forum of Catholic Thought

Culture



Catholic Schools Foundation

Keeping Massachusetts dollars for Massachusetts kids

Help us expand our reach! Please share this article on social media

Submit a Letter to the Editor
Michael
Reardon

''I'm not going to leave money on the table when it could help our kids." This is a quote from New York Gov. Kathy Hochul when she made the decision for New York to opt-in to the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit on Oct. 9, 2026.
Gov. Hochul's decision was not about politics. It was about making sure New York students could benefit from an opportunity already available under federal law. If Gov. Hochul chose not to opt-in, taxpayers in New York would still be able to take advantage of the federal tax credit, but their funds would support students in a state other than New York. She made a practical decision to support students in her state.
Massachusetts has not made a decision to opt-in. Gov. Maura Healey, appropriately, was waiting for the regulations to arrive before making a decision. The rules are now out, and it is time for the governor to decide. Not opting in means that millions of charitable dollars generated from the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit will leave Massachusetts to help students in other states. This is not political, it is practical. As Gov. Hochul noted, "We believe this program has the potential to bring millions of additional dollars to New York students and families without taking a single dollar from public schools or our state or local budgets." This is not political, it is practical.

Calling the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit a "scholarship" tax credit is a bit of misnomer. This name is unfortunate because the funds generated from this tax credit help all children and can be especially helpful to public school students. This bill allows funds to be used for tutoring, enrichment, technology, and other services to help students succeed. Yes, it also provides for scholarship support for private and Catholic schools, but this is about all children having access to opportunity, not a select group of children.
The recently released federal regulations make this opportunity especially meaningful for public school students. They include provisions that streamline income verification for students receiving certain federal benefits and students in foster care, and allow schools in qualifying high-poverty communities to identify students for tutoring and special-needs services without requiring each family to individually verify income. These provisions could help direct additional resources to students who need them most.
While the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit offers significant opportunities for public school students, it can also make a meaningful difference for families choosing Catholic and other private schools. Right now, in the Archdiocese of Boston, one in eight students attends a Catholic school because of scholarship support from the Catholic Schools Foundation (CSF). Families are sacrificing to give their children this opportunity and still need a little help to make it work. They make these sacrifices to send their children to Catholic schools because they know it is an investment in their child's future. They know that their school will be inspired by the Gospel, students will be held accountable to be thoughtful, moral people, and they will be well prepared academically. This is not just a good feeling. Catholic schools have better outcomes for students.
The need for continued philanthropic support for Catholic schools is required regardless of whether or not Massachusetts opts-in to the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit. The need continues to grow for families for whom a Catholic education would be life changing. CSF must continue to meet that need. The work of Catholic schools is too important to not succeed! There is not an army of sisters, priests and brothers coming over the hill to provide the living scholarships as they did in the past. Today, this is up to us.
If Massachusetts does opt-in, students in Catholic, private, and most of all, public schools will benefit at no cost to taxpayers, and with no decrease in public school funding. The Federal Scholarship Tax Credit has become political, and it needs to be practical. Even if one disagrees with the law, the fact is, not opting-in simply means that politics are being put above students. Not opting-in means a choice is being made to have philanthropic dollars from Massachusetts taxpayers sent to support students in other states. Keeping Massachusetts dollars for Massachusetts kids is just common sense.

- Michael B. Reardon is executive director of the Catholic Schools Foundation, www.CSFBoston.org.



Help us expand our reach! Please share this article on social media

Recent articles in the Culture & Events section