Archbishop McCarrick not the first prelate with seminarian abuse charges

Bishop Anthony J. O'Connell of Palm Beach, Fla., resigned in 2002 when he acknowledged there was a basis in fact to the claims of a former high school seminarian at a seminary in Hannibal, Mo., in the Diocese of Jefferson City, where then-Father O'Connell had served 20 years as spiritual director and rector. He is pictured in an undated photo from the Diocese of Jefferson City. (CNS photo/courtesy The Catholic Missourian)

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Archbishop Theodore E. McCarrick, the retired archbishop of Washington, is not the first U.S. prelate to have been accused of abusing seminarians under his care, only the most recent.

The first known instance was in 2002, when Bishop Anthony J. O'Connell of Palm Beach, Florida, resigned that June when he acknowledged there was a basis in fact to the claims of a former high school seminarian at a seminary in Hannibal, Missouri, in the Diocese of Jefferson City, where then-Father O'Connell had served 20 years as spiritual director and rector.

There were differences. Archbishop McCarrick's victims were college seminarians, while Bishop O'Connell's were high school seminarians. Archbishop McCarrick had been retired for more than a decade when news reports surfaced about his prior abuse; Bishop O'Connell was in his second appointment leading a U.S. diocese when his history of abuse first broke.

Two months after the first allegations against then-Cardinal McCarrick were publicized, his case is far from settled. He resigned his position in the College of Cardinals July 28, and he awaits a Vatican trail on the allegations with a possible penalty that could remove him completely from the clerical state. A criminal report was filed in a Virginia suburb of Washington, where Archbishop McCarrick served for five years, by one of his accusers who had moved there from New Jersey, where he alleged the abuse took place.

Bishop O'Connell reached settlements with two of his first accusers in 2004, nearly two years after the allegations were first reported. He was sent to a monastery in South Carolina until his death in 2012.

Each prelate has had at least one complainant say the abuse continued into their adulthood.

The Irish-born Bishop O'Connell had been transferred from Knoxville to stem the crisis following the resignation in 1998 of Bishop J. Keith Symons, who resigned after having admitted to molesting several altar boys early in his priesthood. He is the first U.S. bishop known to have resigned for abuse.

After Bishop O'Connell's resignation, St. John Paul II appointed then-Bishop Sean P. O'Malley to the Florida diocese. He had earned positive notices in cleaning up a clergy sex abuse scandal after being appointed to the Diocese of Fall River, Massachusetts, in 1992.

"The church may seem distorted by sin and scandal, but it is the body of Christ," then-bishop O'Malley said at a press conference after his installation. Less than two months after his arrival, he issued the first draft of a proposed sex abuse policy that said: "No diagnosed pedophile will receive an assignment in the Diocese of Fall River." In December of that year the diocese reached a financial settlement with 68 people who said they were sexually abused by Father James Porter, who was believed to have abused as many as 150.

However, Cardinal O'Malley stayed in Palm Beach only nine months before he was appointed archbishop of Boston, which was the epicenter of the abuse crisis when it erupted in 2002.

Because he was a bishop, Bishop O'Connell's conduct did not fall under the norms the U.S. bishops adopted in Dallas in the spring of 2002 to deal with priests accused of sexual abuse of minors.

Those norms require bishops to suspend credibly accused priests from ministry and submit their cases to the Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith for a determination as to how the case should be adjudicated. Many priests have been laicized under those norms.

That November, the bishops approved a five-point "Statement of Episcopal Commitment" applying the Dallas charter to themselves, "respecting always church law as it applies to bishops."

If an allegation of abuse of a minor is made against a bishop "the metropolitan," or archbishop of an ecclesiastical province, "will be informed," it said. If an allegation is made against the archbishop, the statement says, the province's senior bishop -- the member of the province who was first ordained a bishop -- is to be informed.

"In cases of financial demands for settlements involving allegations of any sexual misconduct by bishops, the metropolitan will be informed," it added, or to the senior bishop in the case of a demand against the metropolitan. The statement also committed the bishops to "fraternal support, fraternal challenge and fraternal correction" of one another regarding their decisions on clergy sex abuse.

But the National Review Board, which is charged with addressing clerical sexual misconduct in the church, said in an Aug. 28 statement the bishops' Statement of Episcopal Commitment was "ineffective and needs to be revised into a meaningful, actionable commitment. In particular, the notion of 'fraternal correction' must outline concrete steps that will be taken when a bishop is alleged to have committed sexual abuse or has failed to respond immediately and without hesitation when a cleric is accused of sexual abuse."

There has been a long church tradition against laicizing a bishop, according to Father Robert Kaslyn, professor of canon law at The Catholic University of America in Washington. The only recent instance was that of former Zambian archbishop Emmanuel Milingo, who was dismissed from the priesthood in 2009, three years after incurring excommunication. Milingo had married a woman in 2001 in a mass Unification Church ceremony, headed groups that called for the abolition of priestly celibacy and ordained bishops against Vatican orders.

Prior to that, Father Kaslyn said, there were two cases in the 19th century of bishops who wanted to join monasteries as priests and asked to be removed from the clerical state.

However, bishops accused of sexual misconduct, or for covering up such misconduct, have not been laicized. That would include Bishops O'Connell and Symons. The late Cardinal Hans Hermann Groer of Vienna was not laicized after being forced to step down in 1995 amid numerous allegations of sexual abuse of seminarians and was subsequently ordered by the Vatican not to engage in any public ministry.

- - -

Follow Pattison on Twitter: @MeMarkPattison

Listening church: Pope gives new vision for Synod of Bishops

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- The Synod of Bishops increasingly should be a structure for listening to the Catholic faithful, demonstrating a local bishop's concern ...

Director of Courage releases letter on Penn. abuse report

Washington D.C., Sep 17, 2018 CNA.- Courage International, an apostolate to support people with same sex-attraction in leading chaste lives, has issued ...

Richmond bishop apologizes to victims; commits to opening, reviewing files

RICHMOND, Va. (CNS) -- In celebrating the Diocese of Richmond's first Mass of Atonement for victims of abuse Sept. 14, Bishop Barry C. Knestout apologized ...

Stanford University to remove saint's name from some properties

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- California's Stanford University will strip the name of 18th-century Franciscan friar, St. Junipero Serra, from some of its properties ...

Catholic Charities distributes disaster relief to areas hit by Florence

RALEIGH, N.C. (CNS) -- The Carolinas were hard hit with record rainfall and flooding rivers from tropical storm Florence since it made landfall Sept. ...

Archbishop Lori assures diocese he's with them in journey toward healing

WHEELING, W.Va. (CNS) -- In his celebration of Mass at the Cathedral of St. Joseph in Wheeling Sept. 15, Archbishop William E. Lori of Baltimore said ...

Bishop takes a (sky) dive to get pilgrims to Lourdes

HOVE, England (CNS) -- "The Moth has landed," tweeted the Diocese of Arundel and Brighton. The tweet Sept. 14 and a similar post on the diocesan Facebook ...

Words, promises are not enough to prevent abuse, archbishop says

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Inviting presidents of the world's bishops' conference to the Vatican to discuss abuse prevention reflects an understanding that ...

Pope praises Capuchin order's charism of authenticity, simplicity

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Capuchins are called to be men of peace, reconciliation and prayer and to be close to all people, Pope Francis told members of the ...

Path to healing starts with seeking forgiveness, Cardinal Wuerl says

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- A "Season of Healing" for sexual abuse survivors began in the Archdiocese of Washington with a Sept. 14 Mass at the Cathedral of St. ...

Archbishop McCarrick's unofficial role in Vatican-China relations

Vatican City, Sep 17, 2018 CNA.- Following reports that the Holy See and the People’s Republic of China could be about to sign an agreement ...

Archbishop Chaput: When we forget faith, we forget our humanity

Spokane, Wash., Sep 14, 2018 CNA.- When man tries to cling to reason and separate himself from faith, he forgets who he is and loses his source of hope, ...

Pope Francis warns priests against living a double life

Palermo, Italy, Sep 15, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- During a day trip to Sicily Saturday, Pope Francis told priests and religious to fight their vices and strive ...

What is the pontifical secret?

Vatican City, Sep 14, 2018 CNA.- Following the allegations made by Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò about the case of Archbishop Theodore McCarrick, ...

Vatican publishes list of synod participants, including papal nominees

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- To the list of members of the Synod of Bishops elected by national bishops' conferences, Pope Francis added cardinals from 14 countries, ...

Addicts and their loved ones talk about life with opioid addiction

ARLINGTON, Va. (CNS) -- It was a Saturday night, and Billy was eating pizza and watching a sporting event in the basement bedroom of his residence, a ...

Signers of letter hope Vatican meeting will bring needed steps on crisis

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Signers of an open letter from Catholic women to Pope Francis urging "truth" and "transparency" on the growing sex abuse crisis expressed ...

Community 'overwhelmed and shell-shocked' after gas explosions, says pastor

LAWRENCE -- Volunteers at St. Patrick Church's Cor Unum Meal Center were serving dinner when multiple natural gas explosions and fires broke out in homes ...

Down to earth: Vatican brings together world's meteorite curators

CASTEL GANDOLFO, Italy (CNS) -- Rocks, mineral debris and even dust from space are kept in special collections, museums and laboratories all over the ...

Algerian martyrs to be beatified in Algeria Dec. 8

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- The beatification of 19 martyrs of Algeria, including the seven Trappist monks of Tibhirine, will be celebrated Dec. 8 in Oran, ...

'Anything but a picnic' - Cardinal Dolan on the Church's summer of scandal

New York City, N.Y., Sep 14, 2018 CNA.- Cardinal Timothy Dolan has spoken about how the extended sexual abuse scandals facing the Church have taken a ...

Restoring and reimagining: Transformation at the Cathedral of the Holy Cross

BOSTON -- Considered by many to be the heart of the Archdiocese of Boston, the Cathedral of the Holy Cross is the largest Catholic church in New England, ...

Archdiocese says Cardinal O'Malley will personally review all abuse letters

BRAINTREE (CAN) -- The Archdiocese of Boston has announced changes to the way it will process and respond to letters addressed to Cardinal Séan P. ...

CM receives $2.5M grant from Yawkey Foundations

West Roxbury -- Catholic Memorial, a college-preparatory school for boys in grades 7 to 12, announced Sept. 5 that they have received a $2.5 million grant ...

Father Christian Ohazulume removed from ministry

BRAINTREE -- The Archdiocese announced on Sept. 11 that it had removed a priest from ministry after receiving an allegation that he sexually abused a ...

From Cardinal Seán's blog

This week I am in transit to Rome in anticipation of the next meeting of the C9 Council of Cardinals. So, I have asked Vivian Soper to share some reflections ...

Kavanaugh's birth control comments spur controversy -- What did he say?

Washington D.C. (CNA) -- Opponents of Judge Brett Kavanaugh have suggested that a reference to birth control pills as "abortion-inducing drugs" during ...

Missouri to enforce abortion regulations in wake of appeals court ruling

Jefferson City, Mo. (CNA) -- Missouri's health department announced Monday that it will immediately being enforcing state laws regulating abortion clinics ...

Book tells about behind-the-scenes search for St. Peter's bones

HOUSTON (CNS) -- Two Houston men shared a journey through centuries of history and a decades-long archaeological dig under the Vatican to unveil a story ...

Update way priests are chosen, accompanied, pope tells new bishops

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- The best way to help the Catholic Church, Pope Francis told new bishops, is not by pointing fingers and creating scapegoats, but ...

Vatican confirms ongoing Sistine Chapel Choir finance inquiry

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- The Vatican confirmed an ongoing investigation into financial irregularities involving the directors of the Sistine Chapel Choir. ...

After meeting pope, cardinal says he's hopeful about addressing crisis

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Cardinal Daniel N. DiNardo of Galveston-Houston struck a determinedly hopeful tone after his long-awaited meeting with Pope Francis ...

DA clears Indiana bishop of misconduct, says claim has harmed prelate

FORT WAYNE, Ind. (CNS) -- The Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend welcomed findings by a Pennsylvania district attorney that cleared Bishop Kevin C. Rhoades ...

Cardinal DiNardo calls meeting with pope lengthy, fruitful

Vatican City, Sep 13, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Cardinal Daniel DiNardo has called a Sept. 13 meeting between Pope Francis and leaders from the Church in United ...

What do Church abuse policies mean by 'vulnerable adult?'

Denver, Colo., Sep 12, 2018 CNA.- A Vatican summit this February will gather the presidents of bishops’ conferences from around the world. While ...

'Elitist, clericalist' church allows abuse to thrive, pope says

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Sexual and physical abuse by priests and religious and the scandal of its cover-up by church authorities thrive in countries where ...

Cardinal Wuerl to ask pope to accept his resignation

Washington D.C., Sep 12, 2018 CNA.- An archdiocesan spokesman has confirmed that Cardinal Donald Wuerl will soon ask Pope Francis to accept his resignation ...

Pope accepts resignation of West Virginia bishop as inquiry into abuse claims launched

Vatican City, Sep 13, 2018 CNA/EWTN News.- Pope Francis Thursday accepted the resignation of Bishop Michael J. Bransfield from the pastoral government ...