Xia Yu and Philip Ng star in a scene from the movie "Birth of the Dragon." The Catholic News Service classification is A-III -- adults. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is PG-13 -- parents strongly cautioned. Some material may be inappropriate for children under 13. (CNS photo/BH Tilt)
Help us expand our reach! Please share this article
NEW YORK (CNS) -- No one goes to a kung fu movie to savor plot nuances. They're all about tightly choreographed kicks and punches, and pleasing epigrammatic dialogue about near-monastic discipline and self-control, mixed in with a dusting of Asian spice.
"Birth of the Dragon" (BH Tilt) -- a fictional retelling of a real confrontation between Bruce Lee (Philip Ng) and Chinese martial-arts master Wong Jack Man (Xia Yu) in San Francisco in 1964 -- hits all these notes, but dully. There's far more talking than punching, plus a subplot involving Chinese criminals that comes off as stereotyped.
The good intentions and moral core of the film, adapted from an article by Michael Dorgan, are on display, though. Director George Nolfi and screenwriters Christopher Wilkinson and Stephen J. Rivele show Lee -- a future martial-arts legend who died at only 32 in a 1973 accident -- as cocky and engaging. He teaches his craft to groups, including white men, with the intention of popularizing it while building his nascent screen career.
Lee wants to make kung fu "bigger than the Hula Hoop," he claims. "Bigger than Coca-Cola."
Most of the screen time, though, is taken up by Lee's student, Steve (Billy Magnussen). His earnest goofiness ties all the plot threads together -- as when he becomes enamored of shy waitress Xiulan Quan (Qu Jingjing) who's actually a "possession of Auntie Blossom" (Xing Jin), a crime lord who brought her to America.